Skip to main content?

wa li fb pin tw in tum red sms call


 Reviewed 28 October 2017 share-a-picture Or go to discussion?join-the-discussion dogphoto

==> "Come here! Come here now! Come here right NOW!!" - Sounds somewhat familiar?

How to make your dog come when YOU want


For many dog owners in general (not just German Shepherd owners), the Recall is a challenging training objective. And that's mainly because they didn't first hone dog Leash Training.

Key point #1 for a successful Recall:

First hone your GSD Leash Training

And if you have a GSD puppy, also implement the puppy-specific points of leash training

Of course it's only natural not to think of leash training when we get a dog: The first thing we do when we get a dog or puppy is to CALL it to us, isn't it?!

In fact, with a new puppy (where it would matter most to start the right way), we typically call it all the time, and give it affection all the time: "Ohh, look my darling, here." - "Ahh, my sweety, what do we have there?" - "Now, this is SPECIALLY for you!" - "Mmmh, isn't this yummy, yummy?!" etc etc. All our attention revolves around our new baby (ahem, puppy).

All this is natural, yes. - But is it helping the long-term relationship with our dog?

No. Clearly not. So much not, that Dan, the impressive online video dog trainer, even established one of his five "Golden Rules" just for this! - His Rule No 4: Everything on your terms.

To be frank, my own first thought when I studied his comprehensive dog training approach was: Huuh, that's a bit harsh, isn't it? Almost inhumane, not to allow your dog to start the attention, the affection, to decide where to go, etc. Never! Really? Yes, Dan recommends to stick to all 5 rules. Everyone in the family. All the time.

The reason why I was a bit skeptic at first: Because, a) GSDs in general are more attentive, sophisticated, and autonomous than most other dog breeds, and b) specifically, our own GSDs always got a lot of "freedom to decide" and they are treated rather like "partners" than "pets" or "servants", because that's imperative when you have GSDs as Protection Dogs (will feature in a future MYGERMANSHEPHERD PERODICAL).

However, when we then actually tried various aspects of his comprehensive dog training approach, we realized that indeed it does make the dogs calmer, more content, and seemingly happier too. It does further improve the relationship with our dogs!

I wouldn't often suggest that you try Dan's dog training too if I wasn't very happy with it myself. As often said, it's not GSD-specific but since GSDs are dogs as well after all, his dog training videos have been enormously helpful to us - and so it will be helpful to you too when you try it.

So, Key point #2 for a successful Recall:

Train yourself to ignore your dog whenever (s)he comes to you without being called

Not in a mean, harsh way. But in the way already the mum does it with the litter pups.

Admittedly, this is the hardest bit of the training for all of us who love our dog! Not only that we actually like to get unsolicited attention and affection (for once! grin ), no, we may find it somewhat "cruel" not to give in, right?

However, no matter how much we are used to treat our GSDs almost like human beings, we must not forget that after all they are animals - with animal-typical traits and needs!

And fact is, no matter how much socialized and how familiar and close our own GSD is to us, being an animal, dogs, the dog will indeed always try to get the upper hand, to dominate us when we show signs of weakness or indecisiveness. Remember the words: dogs dominate.

And, being a dog, (s)he will always get confused and stressed when we show inconsistency in our expectations, commands, and behavior.

I'd strongly suggest you read the above paragraph again, as I fear even my highlighting can't fully relay its significance. neutral

Hence Key point #3 for a successful Recall:

Be clear about what you want from your dog, be decisive, and don't confuse your dog:

  • with inconsistency between your commands and your body language
  • or with inconsistency between what you communicate today and what you communicate tomorrow.

Yes, all these three key points come before you even start with the Recall. Uuups! rolleyes

If you don't keep this order of training the Recall, don't be surprised when your GSD may never come reliably when you call your dog. Meaning, sometimes (s)he'll come, but other times (s)he won't. wink

How to train your dog 100% successful Recalls

Now on to the actual steps of training the Recall in a way that almost guarantees you 100% success rate when you call your dog:

Step 1: Start today and inside the house, and over the entire week (and thereafter) only ever give your dog praise, pats, cuddles and other affection when you have called your dog to you. Conversely, when your dog comes to you without being called and is seeking just that (praise, pats, cuddles and other affection), then ignore the dog completely.

The only (obvious) exception is if your dog has a genuine need (and right!) to get your attention - say because it may be ill, needs to pee, needs water, aims to protect you from some looming danger that you haven't yet noticed, or is traumatized from a prior owner or some incident.

In any of these or similar cases, of course you should be very generous with attention and affection even if your dog is obviously seeking it.

When (s)he say lays the head or a paw on your lap, huddles against your legs, or simply puts on that begging look, look away, walk away, or use the outside of your hand or arm to gently move your dog away. The first few times this may be hard for you and confusing for your dog (if not used to this), but the rewards for the relationship between you two go way beyond the pure Recall! You will be surprised!

Step 2: Likewise, start today, and over the entire week (and thereafter) only ever give your GSD a meal or treats(!) when you have called your dog to you. Conversely, when your dog shows that unambiguous look which you know means "I'd now like a treat please", then again ignore your dog completely.

Wait a while before you serve the meal (and of course don't forget the brief Gesture Eating when you finally do serve the meal), go in another room, do something else. Just wait until your dog is calm, not begging, and maybe not even thinking of the meal or treat, because your dog is distracted by something else.

Step 3: From now on, when you call your GSD (remember, for now we are still inside the house), and your dog doesn't immediately shoot towards you but then comes a bit later, ignore your dog - like (s)he just ignored you too! Same level, same length.

Because, your dog just decided to ignore you to demonstrate its dominance in the Pack structure, as considered by your dog. - Remember that all dog breeds will always consider themselves as the Pack Leader, every day anew, unless you always show them that you are the Pack Leader.

Exactly this you achieve here by giving your dog only one chance to come when called - and then to get whatever you intended to give. If your GSD decides not to make use of that one chance, then within a few times/days only (s)he will have completely understood that the chance is lost with the first call. Because thereafter (s)he is being ignored.

Needless to say, don't call your dog away from its food or "toileting".

Also, don't say anything when your dog just didn't come when called (like "No, you just ignored me, now I ignore you!", or "This is part of your training, you see, you better come when I call you!"...).

Don't even look at your dog, no matter how begging or cute (s)he looks. wink

Step 4: Try to figure out what your dog LOVES. Initially, motivate your dog to come immediately when called by randomly giving just that. Not every time - then it would lose its high attraction - but sometimes.

Contrary to many dog trainers (including Doggy Dan), I don't believe in giving many food treats at all, and certainly NONE in training: It is the wrong incentive!

Besides, it is often very hard to wean a dog off the food treats once they got used to them. And if you actually take the "treats" from the meal (as generally suggested) then the "treats" of course don't have the attraction that treats should have. You get my point?

Nothing though speaks against the other common suggestion: training just before meal times. wink

It's a given that you use what dog trainers love to call positive reinforcement, for training the Recall as much as for anything else.

Avoid what they call negative reinforcement, like threatening the dog with a harsh voice, actions, or longer-lasting withdrawal of attention and affection, food, potty-going, or similar.

You may not immediately notice it as such, but "negative reinforcement" used for a dog completely ruins the relationship: trust, unconditional protection, real companionship, and genuine affection rather than primarily seeking treats...

Step 5: Only when you have mastered all of the above inside the house (where there are little to no distractions), start to practice the Recall outside the house.

Initially, go to the less crowded places, and after a while of successful leash walking, take off the leash, say "Go!" (or whatever command you use to release your dog in order to be free to do what it wants), and let your dog run around on its own account.

Then after 5 minutes or so, call your dog (once! - but make sure (s)he heard you) and while doing so even walk away from your dog, indicating you are "leaving". With all the inhouse-training before (see above), your GSD should now immediately speed towards you, whether or not you show a food treat. (If it doesn't, no problem, you have just tried your first Recall outside. Practice the same routine more often now.)

If you have a long leash (you should really, see GSD Leash Training), and of course particularly if you have reason to fear that your dog may not come when called, switch to the long leash first when you take of the short leash: Let your dog run around while you retain control through the long leash.

Step 6 (often forgotten!): Now continue to practice the Recall in lots of different environments and lots of different situations, and at different times of the day and night.

Key point #4 for a successful Recall:

Practice under increasingly more distractive conditions

Because: While your dog may now always reliably come when called in the standard places and situations, this may be very different when say there's suddenly another large dog, a lonely large piece of meat at a barbecue, or any other highly attractive distraction.

Most of our own GSDs in the past, we trained this entire sequence of the Recall within no more than about one week. And then leisurely in different environments whenever there was an opportunity.

Success rate? Almost 100%! And when our GSDs don't come/came then this was because of some underlying issue that still affected that particular situation. - As you will know, generally GSDs can be quite stubborn and when you've done something wrong many will let you know just that. - And people say, dogs have no memory? Pah! They are just more forgiving than humans.

When you adopt the above 4 Key points, and you apply these 6 Steps of Training the Recall, I bet your GSD will very soon speed towards you everytime you call your dog! Just remember not to overdo it: The less you call your dog (the less restrictive and/or dominant you are, really) the more impact it will have when you do it!

More so: When you adopt the above 4 Key points, and you apply these 6 Steps of Training the Recall, the relationship with your GSD will be lifted onto another level of bonding and companionship! Like we did (and our neighbors and friends), you too will notice the vast difference a proper Recall makes to the quality of life, for your GSD as well as for you.



  • Before you even start training your dog to come when called regardless of the situation and temptation, you MUST adopt certain key points, or you will often be disappointed (and sometimes maybe in danger!) when your dog doesn't come when called:
    • Key point #1: Start with GSD Leash Training and/or Puppy Leash Training the day you get your dog. Don't let weeks or months pass by training calling your pups/dog and giving affection just because "it is so cute!"
    • Key point #2: Train yourself to rather ignore your dog when (s)he comes to you without being called
    • Key point #3: Be clear about what you want from your dog, be decisive, and don't confuse your dog with inconsistency
    • Key point #4: Practice under increasingly more distractive conditions
  • Start inside the house with certain things seemingly unrelated to Training the Recall but actually making all the difference:
    • Step 1: From now on, only ever give your GSD praise, pats, cuddles and other affection when you have called your dog to you. While when your dog comes to you without being called and is seeking your attention and/or affection, then ignore your dog entirely. - But please do note my definitive exceptions to this rule (see above).
    • Step 2: Likewise, only ever give your GSD a meal or treats(!) when you have called your dog to you. And never use negative reinforcement, like say calling your dog to you to then put on the lead, scold, or do grooming (s)he doesn't like. Instead, in all such cases you have to walk to your dog.
    • Step 3: Whenever your dog doesn't immediately shoot towards you when called (but maybe then comes a bit later), ignore your dog - like (s)he just ignored you too! You must establish yourself as the accepted Pack Leader, and all of this are crucial parts of it.
    • Step 4: Identify what your German Shepherd LOVES MOST. Then randomly give this your dog (whether forms of affection, food treats, toys, playtime, or real-life rewards) in order to motivate your dog and to reward your dog.
    • Step 5: Only once you have mastered the above, start to practice the Recall outside the house, and initially choose the least distractive environments for this. Consider using a long line to keep control over your dog despite the increased freedom for both of you.
    • Step 6: Finally, practice the Recall in lots of different environments and lots of different situations.
  • Dan, the professional online dog trainer has many insightful videos of very different situations from which he successfully recalls his dogs.
  • When you adopt the above 4 Key points, and you apply the 6 Steps of Training the Recall, then the Recall will work reliably almost 100% of the time, and in addition the bonding and companionship with your GSD will improve dramatically too!

adult GSDIf ever you appreciate the immense work to maintain this uniquely helpful house, feel free to donate a meal.
As .ORG we depend on your (rare!) donations: however small it helps, THANKS SO MUCH!


PLEASE SHARE with your circle what we share with you:

wa li fb pin tw in tum red sms call

MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORGAny problem with the social share buttons, PLEASE say here to help everyone.

Join the discussion


Jonathan: Thank you for your period advice. It is excellent! My GSD puppy is now 8 months and we read your advice regularly.

Dwayne: I love this site and the info you post onto it. Thanks again!!!!

Penny: Thanks for making your great articles available to all of us. it's nice to know that a recommended product is actually available in my country.

Stay with us and your dog will stay with you, both of you healthy and well-behaved.
If you are ever unhappy with anything we write, do or don't do, we want to be the first to know, thanks.

Disclaimer: Always apply your own common sense when you follow anyone's suggestions. As much as your dog is special (s)he may react different too. Note that for privacy reasons we do not use the everything infiltrating Google Analytics scripts. For a trial period we do currently use a Pinterest pixel to monitor ad spend versus referred visitors from Pinterest only: You can control your Pinterest privacy settings here. If you click through to a vendor and buy something, the vendor may share a commission with us or may not, only Amazon links always should.

© MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG - All content is protected. You must not copy or spin or otherwise change our content to republish it in your name, another one's name or without a name. If you wish to make use of our Intellectual Property Rights contact MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG. Thank you.

There's nothing quite like a healthy and well-behaved dog who freely guards every corner of your home, who brings you peace, who brings you joy
Welcome to The Cynology Hub MyGermanShepherd.Org Saves Health, Cost, Lives!
Devoted to serving all well-meaning dog owners, fosterers, and trainers
We help YOU that YOUR DOG does not end up in a(nother) shelter - Nor at a costly incompetent vet
58 database queries, 0.82 seconds, 20MB