Housebreaking a Puppy


Housebreaking a puppy or potty training a puppy or toilet training a puppy arguably is the most stressful time for a new puppy owner. Obviously unless the mum and litter mates together with the breeder have taken care of that - which they may do, and very well, if you leave the puppy in the litter until age 8 weeks as a minimum.

You may not know, but under normal circumstances puppies actually learn from mum and litter mates to relieve away from their den (the mum doesn't allow the den to be spoiled). And if the breeder is adept in placing the den, then all litter mates may have learned to relieve outside the house (and even on a grassy patch!) as early as age 8 weeks. To find the right breeder, see Questions to ask the breeder which includes what to observe when visiting a breeder.

Unfortunately though, ordinary (read average) breeders don't care, they keep all dogs outside anyway, at a good distance away from their own house. Then how shall the puppies learn to make a difference between indoors and outdoors?!

If you care to have a housebroken puppy later on, then don't start off wrong by getting a puppy from a breeder who doesn't care how to housebreak a puppy. Makes sense, right? So, make sure you get your next German Shepherd puppy from the best German Shepherd breeders, not from some questionable source - who possibly is just money-focused: Do they give the puppies away ASAP to save on further cost?!

Ideally, get an adult rescue dog. On average, rescue dogs are so much easier and more comforting than a puppy!

Puppy housebreaking

But what if you already got a German Shepherd puppy before doing your research on MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG? What if you've got a puddle or poop in your house right now? What do you do? Give the puppy back? Ask for your money back? Give the puppy to a shelter? Get the best book on dog housebreaking alone? Or have your dog use a natural indoor potty?

While an emergency indoor potty always is a smart choice (dogs can have an intestinal upset just like we people do!), undertaking the right puppy housebreaking is essential for domesticated dogs (domus means house, domesticated means "made for the house"). What is the right puppy housebreaking?

Housebreaking a puppy in a way:

  • that the puppy and later the adult dog notifies a family member when the dog feels pressure on bladder or bowel (nudges us or barks or visibly goes to the main door to get our attention)
  • that the puppy and later the adult dog holds on to urine and poop for a reasonable amount of time (for a 12 weeks old GSD puppy reasonable is less than a minute!)
  • that we serve meals at consistent meal times, such that the routine allows the dog's body to adapt (the body does adapt, and bowel and bladder pressure will build up regularly)
  • that in emergencies (when sick) the puppy and later the adult dog will relieve in the house or on the terrace at a suitable spot (and always the same spot) - this is why and where you should put down an emergency potty (in the USA the choice is huge, from natural doggie lawn to stylish indoor potty, and everything in between)
  • and that when not sick the puppy and later the adult dog reliably avoids relieving indoors!

Most approaches to puppy housebreaking that I've seen - both from professional dog trainers and in books - fall short on the final point above (if not already on a prior point), and the dog owner ends up with an adult dog that sometimes still chooses to relieve indoors. That is not reliable housebreaking!

Obviously I have housebroken My New Puppy in accordance with House Training Dogs To Behave Well to get a fully house-trained dog, not just housebroken, and I can report: Since housebreaking him, My New Puppy has never relieved inside the apartment, but so far twice very nicely out on the terrace in a suitable spot when he was sick. Like children, puppies are sick quite often, you may know that, and both "emergency potties" happened at night while I was sleeping.

dog house training

How to housebreak a puppy

Now for the penny pinchers in brief, just the puppy housebreaking bit: What is the quickest and less stressful way of housebreaking a puppy?

oneBy nature, young puppies cannot hold on to their bladder at all, so give your puppy a chance to relieve outdoors where you want every 60 to 90 min MAX (age-specific details etc are in My New Puppy Diary)



twoRestrict a not housebroken puppy to a tiled room or two tiled rooms if you have that (this makes cleaning up very easy, because you won't be ready for a quick walk everytime)



threeWhenever you are at home, do let your puppy run around freely in the tiled room(s), because no one ever learned anything from being locked away, only from practice while free!



fourPosition a wide angle digital camera on a tripod that films your puppy




fiveWhen you take your puppy for a walk stop the camera, and when you come back home turn the camera back on




sixIn the evening, review the 10 seconds at the end of each clip (fast forward is easy with a digital camera)




sevenI can guarantee that on the third day the latest you know exactly what pee signal and what poop signal your puppy shows when the need to relieve is closing in (I knew that on the first evening!) :-D



eightFrom now on, simply watch out consciously for your pup's first signal to relieve, and then take your puppy out immediately - until bladder and bowel strength have built up such that your puppy can hold on for a moment.



If only you follow these few points, you too will have a housebroken puppy within a mere days - not weeks, or months, or years! :-D

The emergency potty you provide for ... emergencies only. How to train the use of the emergency potty only in emergencies, this too is covered in House Training Dogs To Behave Well In A High Value Home. It's complete.

Congratulations! You now have a housebroken puppy! Or even fully house-trained? Most dog owners have not.



  • 1

 Comments via our New Facebook Page Managed by Krystal! - Thank you xx

Just Note:

1. To fight SPAM anything with a link lands in SPAM
2. To go live any bark must be relevant to this page
3. Be polite, introduce yourself with what you found, not with a help request

  30 Site Comments, ZERO SPAM Add one


    I have wanted to buy a German Shepherd for as long as I can remember. I want to buy one and train it while it is on the road with me, I currently work 8-10 hours a day. It would be no different if I were at the house. Would I just be fighting an uphill battle trying to train my pup? Can it be done? He would get plenty of exercise running and hiking with me.


      I am unsure what you mean? You say your GSD would get plenty of exercise like running and hiking, and you also say you want to train your GSD while on the road.
      Do you mean while driving in the car?? You should focus on the traffic :-)
      No, you cannot train ANY dog while in the car, you need more space.
      In other regards, sure you can train your GSD despite being 10 hours on the road (IF your dog truly gets enough exercise!). Indeed, if you have to be out of house all day, you should take your dog with you if you can!
      We cannot leave a pup all day alone. When older, it's a bit different. Then I always recommend to get at least two dogs when you are all day away, so that they have someone to socialize with. This is CRUCIAL to avoid behavior problems. Still, before you leave and straight when you come home, you would NEED to socialize intensely with your dogs, or you will face sever health and behavior problems.



    Sorry about asking an irrelevant question for this post but I could not find your email address to contact you directly.

    I have two playful cats and if I use your design of crate for my new 8 week old male pup (which will come by end of January 2014), don't you think it may encourage the puppy to play with cats during night time and cause bad behaviors?
    I have bunch of cables behind my TV and I wonder if he gets up at night and start chewing on them.
    Also do you have a chart that shows how much exercise on average a German Shepherd dog should get through his/her lifetime?

    Allen Heydari


      Hi Allen, no problem, your question actually fits perfectly on this page.
      Yes, do not let your 8 week old pup wandering around the house while you are asleep! Only after you are sure your (older) pup is fully house-trained the way WE HERE understand house training (more than housebreaking!) - the linked book is currently FREE, grab it quickly!! It's all in there.



    Thanks for the quick response. I just have downloaded your book. Now, should I put him in Kennel till he gets housetrained?

    Also how long do you think it will take for a male GSD on average to get housetrained?


      You have it now, for free, why don't you just start reading? I couldn't say it any better here in a quickie message ;-)
      When finished let me know through your review :-)



    I have read both of your books on puppy and high value house but still I dont see anywhere in those books that you have talked about what we should do till the puppy is house trained. I will get my puppy in three weeks from a breeder. Please let me know if I should keep the puppy in kennel for several days before I house trained him or not?


      Allen, maybe you overlooked it, I wrote "Keep your puppy in a non-carpeted area during those first few days" (until house-trained; remember, it doesn't take weeks with our approach), and "when your pup is not, constant observation is necessary".

      Look, it is only sensible not to have the persian rugs rolled out on the day you get a new pup. I know, in some households it can be a struggle to temporarily arrange living in a room with tiles, linoleum, or whatever (some people have NO such room), but on the other hand, if we don't make such temporary adaptations, we will be upset when our new pup pees on some valuable stuff (and being upset is not a good start for a great relationship).

      I also found that when we have to make such "uncomfortable" arrangements, we are much more eager to identify the pup's individual potty signals quickly (camera)! While dog owners who avoid to adapt (even if it's only for a few days), tend to "accept" that bad habits develop. And often, before they know it, 5 months have passed, and they still haven't identified the pup's potty signals, and they still haven't established a potty routine/ dog walk routine! (I read that out of help requests all the time, it's so common!)

      Hence, when we get/got a new dog (pup or adult), one person always had to be at home during the first week, and we willingly chose life a bit "uncomfortable" during the first few days, this motivated us to know the potty signals on the second or third day (max), and the potty routine described in the book was established that same day or (if evening) the very next day!

      That way, in under a week we can make the house as comfy again as we like. Still, at night (when we can't observe the new dog), we will keep the dog in a non-carpeted "safe" room/area (no wiring etc, as described in the book). If you have NO such area, obviously you will have to lock your new dog/pup in a crate (ie kennel) during the night (but take the pup out for a walk every few hours anyway) - otherwise you'll have to accept that you may wake up to a small mess.

      Does this make sense to you?



    Thank you so much for the info. I guess my best option would be kennel at this point then.



    I just bought a German Sheperd, AKC Registered Puppy. I have had him now for 3 days, and the young male pup still will not associate going to the bathroom while outside. He always wants to play, jump on me, or bite at my legs.

    I take him out last thing at night before crating him, and first thing in the morning, and within 10 minutes of eating and drinking, but it still wants to both pee and poop inside the house. I'm getting frustrated with it's behavior because I have a toddler in the house also, and don't want germs transferred from the dog's waste.

    Any ideas or help?! Thanks!


      >Any ideas or help?!
      Loads: Did you see the Puppy 101?

      With your situation, now give particular attention to:
      - urgent and comprehensive socialization!!!
      - bite inhibition training
      - Feeding Routine
      - Ignoring Attention-Seeking
      - controlled play-fighting

      While Housebreaking is minor (will only take a few days with our approach).



    I subscribed to about 2 weeks ago. I have tried to login, and it will not let me, claiming no known subscription for email. I received my welcome email to the entered email, and have also received a periodical. HELP! I have some questions/concerns as well about my GSD puppy, Ruger, that will be coming home within the week that I am hoping you can help me find answers/solutions to.
    Thank you for all you do,
    (I know this isn't a relevant article, but my concerns are puppy related)


      Sarah, nowhere it says that you need to "login", nor that you can "login". Only members can. Not subscribers. Hope this helps. Thanks.


    Tim. My 10 week old Female VS spends most of the day with me and my my other dog (8 year old Female Doberman. The GS is fed in the morning. She plays in our large yard throughout the day with me and the donor. Often when she cones into the house she will immediately on the tile o
    Floor even though she just pre d outside. At night I keep her in a large wire crate next to my bed. If I leave her anywhere else she cried all night long. I get up twice a night to take her outside ans she usually prees. In the morning the paper I lay down in her site crate if full of poop and pre. I do not give her water or food on the evening. I keep her in the crate because otherwise she soils the floor. Why is she randomly peering in the house after being outside all day? Why is she peering and pooping in the crate she sleeps in. I want to get her house trained. Any suggestions outside of what is in the house training a puppy book. ?


      Bill, you cannot mean any of my own books as I don't have a house training a puppy book. If you only seek house training advice, I suggest Verni Fogarsi's housebreaking book (her book title is misleading).

      However, you have far more issues than just housebreaking. Foremost, you have raised a 10 week old pup that already learned that she is the Pack leader!
      In all diplomacy, from what you write, you are doing everything wrong.

      If I were you, I would strictly adhere to the Puppy Development Guide and to House Training Dogs To Behave Well.
      What you write shows that so far, you apply nothing of that. :-(
      You need to ask yourself, why?


    I have a female GSD nd we live in a apartment. We want to train her to go pee nd poo outside the house or at terrace. How we do this? She do this in all over the house.. she is 5 weeks old. We give 6 times food in a day as doctor prescribed. She goes potty 3-4 times in a day. We want place for her to go there..if it is a particular place or in balcony or at terrace. Not all over in the house... please email me how to do that.


    Hey Tim,

    I purchased your book "puppy 101 for dog lovers" and have read it. I am also subscribed to your periodicals. I am trying to train my pup who is 8 weeks old using the techniques you outlined. The results have been very good and satisfying, it keeps both the pup and me calm :)

    I stay with my dad and mom in the same house and they haven't read your book as they have a hectic schedule. I have two questions:
    1. My pup is 40% house broken already but is not house trained. If she goes for the sofa or the slippers. Should freeze/isolation be used to restrain her or are there other indications to watch out for. As I feel guilty not giving her free movement within my home.

    2. At times my puppy goes for my parent's slippers / trousers and their reactions would be mostly to try to push her off and if she comes again they would scold her and pull their legs up if they are on the couch. Their reactions are not consistent to mine, as I would use your techniques. Will this confuse the dog? What do I do?


      Jai, the pup only 8 weeks old? And you already seeing the results from using the techniques? That's good but I wonder how young you got the pup. It sounds like the puppy missed on a lot of what you (hopefully) took in from the Puppy Development Guide: Litter Socialization. Hm?
      So you'll need to make up for that loss during Family Socialization, ie NOW. Right now, for the next four to six weeks minimum. Yes, I would suggest to use exactly the techniques outlined in the book - that's why I put them there.

      Another worry I have: You write your parents are (in short, in my words) No-knows, AND counteract your training approach. That's terrible, all the more for an 8w old puppy!
      I am unsure about your age, but I am sure from your writing that you have the skill to SHOW your parents HOW TO BEHAVE WELL with the pup. Ie use the moments where your parents come home from their "hectic schedule" to pass on as much as you can of what you learned from the book and your success with the puppy already. And make very clear to them: If they are interfering with your training (and confuse the pup!), they are going to have a lot of "dog problems" in 8 weeks! Pl check in the book: EVERYONE in the family has to adhere to the training approach.

      Pl re-read the whole book, with particular attention to:
      Collar Freeze/Isolation
      Feeding Routine

      Let me know how you get on a week after that.


    Thanks Tim. Shall do as u suggest. I got the pup a week back, so it spent 7 weeks with its mom and six littermates. Are there any other book of yours which could be read now for more of your awesome techniques which could be used with 2-3 month old puppies?


      At some point you may want to study House Training Dogs To Behave Well, but for the next 2 months I'd absolutely prefer you get all family members in the same boat as regards the Puppy 101 fundamentals.
      Also, do pay particular attention to the nipping advice and controlled play-fighting for bite inhibition (see your Puppy 101).


    We just got a GS Puppy she's 3 1/2 months. The breeder kept her in an enclosed area with wood chips to potty. She isn't potty trained. We have had her 6 hours taken her our several times even bought chips left in an area and still nothing this poor girl needs to go


    My daughter has a 4 month old German Shepherd pup that she got from a pet store. It is extremely difficult to get her to go potty outside. What are some tips to help with her potty training? She is also leery of being outdoors, as she has lived in a pet store until my daughter bought her about 4 weeks ago. Any help wuld be appreciated. Thank you very much.


    We try to keep our new, almost 9 week old German Shepherd puppy in an enclosed, tiled room at night. We also provide water and a radio for some soft white noise. But after two hours or so, she starts wining and crying so bad even the neighbours can hear her...nothing then calms her. So....we take her to our room where she sleeps in front our bed...even then she seems restless and whined now and then. It's her second night with us.


    Just bought your book on puppy training. We've had several GSD's but not had a puppy for a while and thought would try your techniques. Thank you for a wonderful site.


    Hey so I have an 10 week old german shepherd male and he doesn't work well with being house broken and the nipping and biting I can't get him to stop any suggestions

Bark away ... just note:

1. To fight SPAM anything with a link lands in SPAM
2. To go live any bark must be relevant to this page
3. Be polite, introduce yourself with what you found, not with a help request

 Say it

Jonathan: "Thank you for your period advice. It is excellent! My GSD puppy is now 8 months and we read your advice regularly."
Dwayne: "I love this site and the info you post onto it. Thanks again!!!!"
Penny: "Thanks for making your great articles available to all of us. it's nice to know that a recommended product is actually available in my country."

Stay with us and your dog will stay with you, both of you healthy and well-behaved.
If you are ever unhappy with anything we write, do or don't do, we want to be the first to know, thanks.

Disclaimer: Always apply your own common sense when you follow anyone's suggestions. As much as your dog is special (s)he may react different too.

© MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG - All content is protected. You must not copy or spin or otherwise change our content to republish it in your name, another one's name or without a name. If you wish to make use of our Intellectual Property Rights contact MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG. Thank you.

There's nothing quite like a healthy and well-behaved dog who freely guards every corner of your home, who brings you peace, who brings you joy!
Welcome to MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG We help you that YOUR DOG does not end up in a(nother) shelter!