Skip to main content?

wa li fb pin tw in tum red sms call

Dog Training

 Reviewed 7 January 2019 share-a-picture Or go to discussion?join-the-discussion dogphoto

What you learn here you find nowhere else - unless they copy from us: the Cynology Hub MyGermanShepherd.Org.

Once you appreciate that dog socialization must be your first priority, you can give the right dog training consideration too.

What is the right dog training?

  1. The kind of training that matches your training purpose: "Why do you want to train your dog at all?", "What's it for?"
  2. The kind of training that matches your dog's personality.

Why not your training purpose and your personality?

Because your training purpose may not match your personality. wink You will understand more the more you read at this Cynology Hub.

So remember:

The right dog training is what matches:

  1. your training purpose
  2. and your dog's personality!

Training matching Your Training Purpose

Your training purpose I can't know. So until you write your training purpose here, let's continue here with what our training purpose is at MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG:

To build the BEST relationship with our dog

This goes way beyond dog training, yes, but never mind, we love to set the goal high, there is too much mediocrity on dog-related websites already. eek

Training matching Your Dog's Personality

dog personalityUnless you describe your dog here, I cannot know what your dog is and what your dog's personality is. If you like to see an example, Miguel's German Shepherd personality is here.

But even if you have a German Shepherd too(?), yours will be different. And so the breed specific dog personality traits are called dog temperament, and the German Shepherd temperament is here.

The German Shepherd breed personality (=temperament) is what has been bred into this dog for hundreds if not thousands of dog generations. The GSD has been bred to be able to manage a large herd of sheep or other livestock all alone:

  • keeping the herd together
  • bringing strays back to the herd
  • supporting the weak members
  • limiting the boisterous members
  • defending the herd against all kinds of intruders and attackers
  • etc.

Now, the key point to understand is:

Regardless what your training purpose is, if you also want to meet the second premise - to match your dog's personality - then you cannot choose a kind of dog training that ignores your dog's temperament: what your dog has been bred for. For example in this case, the German Shepherd temperament.

Because the dog's temperament is the breed specific part of dog personality.

In the case of the German Shepherd, you cannot choose a kind of dog training that ignores this dog's inbred management personality. Because the GSD has been bred to be the manager of a herd of livestock.

And so, if you don't know and you resist to learn how to build the best relationship with a manager, then a Labrador or Doberman may be a great alternative, just not a German Shepherd, nor a Belgian Shepherd.


IMHO these two herding dogs originally had the most pronounced management personality inbred.

To be successful in managing a group of individuals (a herd of livestock), the German Shepherd has been bred to organize, lead, control, and protect.


Thus to decide and act autonomously! Few dog owners get this critical part of German Shepherd temperament.

Very few if any other dogs have been bred to be autonomous: This markedly distinguishes the original German Shepherd from pretty much all other dogs.

Thus certainly for Training a German Shepherd - and quite possibly for other dogs too - we would be misguided if we followed the herd of dog trainers that teach and apply Obedience Training to the dog. Or today by many preferably called "positive reinforcement training".

Or generally, any kind of dog training that is heavy on dog commands and poor on the trainer's self-reflection.

Right Dog Training

Therefore in my opinion, the right dog training, and certainly the right German Shepherd training is Behavior Training, not Obedience Training.


I developed Behavior Training to overcome the flaws of Obedience Training. Particularly for the modern dog owner household: where the dog owners are at work for most of the day, and so ideally train the dog in a way that the dog behaves well when left alone, with free run of the house.

dog house training

This is NOT achievable with any form of Obedience Training or "positive reinforcement training", clicker training, etc! Explained there why not.

And precisely that is the reason why the majority of dog owners have learned from obedience and "positive reinforcement" dog trainers to keep their dog locked up when they are at work and at night.

This is both sad and unnecessary!

Can you train your dog yourself?

Absolutely! You can train your dog better than a "Pro".

In the Dog Expert Interviews with Reviews I even revealed WHY "accredited" professional dog trainers can only be mediocre at best, and what to do instead. It is enlightening! You may check it out now.

Learning dog training from written words and spoken words may not bring sunshine and a smile on everyone's face, I understand. Seeing all live in videos does.

If that's your case, then the absolute best I have found is The Online Dog Trainer Doggy Dan with his video training series. He truly is a TOP dog trainer, not a dog conditioner like most other professional dog trainers are.


If you've gone through all the above links, you now know precisely how to train your dog right, yes.



adult GSDIf ever you appreciate the immense work to maintain this uniquely helpful house, feel free to donate a meal.
As .ORG we depend on your (rare!) donations: however small it helps, THANKS SO MUCH!


PLEASE SHARE with your circle what we share with you:

wa li fb pin tw in tum red sms call

MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORGAny problem with the social share buttons, PLEASE say here to help everyone.


  77 Site Comments, ZERO SPAM: the spam spam-free oasis on the web grin Add one

  1. mosquito-passing

    My gsd jumps on everyone that shows up at the house.

  2. mosquito-passing

    My goal for both my gsds are to be calm and well behaved. I would like to socialize them around children because in the next two years we will be grandparents.

  3. newbie

    My german shepperd is very busy - understandable of course when barking he just grips my sons dog as if he wants to bite her for some reason when we play ball he never wants to drop the ball but other play things he will bring and drop it but never the ball...

  4. mosquito-passing

    I have a 1 year old puppy who's barking is atrocious! She barks none stop as I'm dishing out food; when she wants to come back in from doing her business outside and ESPECIALLY when I get up to take her out of her crate. As she see's me she goes NUTS. How can I train her NOT to bark?

  5. mosquito-passing

    I have a 3 year old German Shepherd male name Max and he's fiercely protective of me. I want him to learn when you can back off and also how to be protective at the right times

    • supportive

      So that's your training goal then. Now, to match that with the dog's personality you will need to drop any remnant of an Obedience mindset, and focus on your own behavior to set a good example for your dog's behavior: Behavior Training.

      Is that something you are willing to do to reach your training goal?

  6. mosquito-passing

    I brought home an 8 month old gsd, week ago, who was living in his parents home till that date. When I went there with my better half and her brother he was sitting near door and was neither aggressive when we entered the house nor when we approached him. He was all friendly and get on with us in car comfortably. During the journey he vomited, but was relaxed and playful on reaching home. He also played a fetch game at my roof where I had a setup for him. He understandingly showed separation anxiety by not loosing a sight of me but next day some neighborhood kids mimicked barking and he started barking back. I tried to calm him but he did not have any prior training so it was a difficult task. Then I took him out and there is a cat and kittens near our house and he started barking aggressively on them and started shaking. I took him towards another side to relax him but there he saw stray dogs and barked. Cross barking started and I took him back home. I live at first floor and my roof comes downstairs to balcony and from there rooms connect. As I go inside the room he spends this time a balcony and keep barking at cats and dogs downstairs, neighborhood kids and even adults. I started obedience training and he generally responds to sit, come and no commands but if trigger he does not get my attention un till I leave the balcony and then he follows me. On third day he started to bark on every visitor coming into the house, even those he got acquainted with during the walks. He also shakes which is clearly telling that he is afraid like hell. He is afraid of people esp. kids, dogs and cats and even entering car.
    Sometimes I tell him not to worry I am taking care of the situation and he relaxes, but visitors or anyone near our house downstairs, whether people or animals make him crazy. Unfortunately we live in a busy neighborhood, where there are variety of animals downstairs and different people are standing on the street. At night many stray dogs comes to the road to collect food from garbage.
    I am desperate to take this poor baby out of his fears. Please suggest what should I do?


    Hey everyone. I'm in a pretty weird situation right now. I got my GSD as a puppy last year in August and was sent on a deployment for about 9 months. I've been home for about a month now and of course my ex fiance didn't take care of.her at all while I was gone. She is trained in the sense of not peeing and pooping in the house bit she is uncontrollable outside. No matter what she will bark at anyone and is ridiculously hyper and aggressive towards other dogs but not people. She's great with other people. Even strangers. I just found out that my ex fiance who was "taking care of her" was involved with someone else while I was gone so now I'm by myself and trying to figure out where to begin with my GSDs training. I'm willing to put in the work but idk where to begin. She's about 16 months old and I know people say it's never to late but I feel helpless right now. Any suggestions would be great. Thank you


    My 4yr old male un nuetered gsd pulls me whenever he wants to get to his goal. He lunges at unknown dogs but has never bitten anything but his food. Loves people and most dogs and kids. Never has any bad behavior when alone at home. Treat driven. Whith me most of the time. Very aloof. I want to stop the pull aggressive behavior and build a better bond. He is part of our family since 4 months old. No children.

    • supportive

      "Treat driven" - that's where you start first, NO treats at all in training! The result of that approach you are experiencing now already, like everyone else who goes down that kerb.
      You may want to learn Behavior Training, so that you learn how to change your dog's behavior with ease.
      If you're only worried about the pulling, the Leash Training Guide will be plenty.

  9. mosquito-passing

    Hi I need help my German Shepherd attacked a dog across street she doesn't know a ny better the police were called yet again and I have to get rid of her, I don't have the money to train her,.she is my baby girl. Can someone help me please.!


    This is our third gsd and two prior were "ready"made godsends that would go warm your car up and make the morning coffee! Brilliant and obedient with no training at ALL, fast forward our 4 month female was weaned from her mother at only 5 weeks and while she is smarter than most humans, knows her commands is crate and potty trained she violently tugs on leash, barks at EVERYTHING outside and won't obey and walks all over my wife (listens to me) we were spoiled by Samson/Delilah our previous male female gsd's is it the early weaning from mother or lack of proper training or what? HELP

    • supportive

      It's lack of proper training, Sam, yes. Simply do what we teach here, it's there for a reason: it works well that way.

    • supportive

      HI Sam! Have you checked out the book on leash training? It's phenomenal how quickly the techniques worked for Kiera (and she was 2.5years when we applied it!) at 4 months, it should be a breeze! Check out the book section for Dogs Unleashed! Can be read on any device, so no worries. That among the other behaviour training ongoing (as explained in the periodicals and such) should have you back to getting your coffee in the morning lol


    Hi we have a 3 year old gsd. I was away for the last two years with visits every six months and he was looked after by my parents. He has no training at all. He is not very aggressive in general. Yet sometimes when i play with him he starts grabbing me with his front legs and starts humping. If i try to stop he gets aggressive and wants to bite. I give him all his meals and groom him too .i try to train him but this habit of his prevents me from doing so sinceheit'snotapuppy and had considerable strength now.i know he won't bite me intentionally. Yet it is difficult. How do i establish the fact that i am the alpha ?

  12. mosquito-passing

    Hi I have an 11 month old female GSD, she's my first full GSD I have had a GSD/Doberman X boy and a full GSD girl previously and they were both very much my dog and relatively easy to train and both quite calm. Here's my problem my girl Nova is stubborn, very rarely calm especially if my hubby is home and goes down the garden to his garage. She will go frantic to get out there with him. She mouths (a lot) and herds all of us, pulls on the lead and will try to heard me when we're walking. I have tried all sorts of treats with positive reinforcement but she is just not interested. She just wants to do what she wants to do. She knows sit,down and come but only does them when she feels like it. I'm the one that's feeds her, walks her and plays with her but I feel that she thinks she's the boss. I have been to two different trainers and have been told she is high drive and high excitement and I just don't know what to do now. I love my girl but it is a constant daily battle with her. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

    • supportive

      Michelle, it's because you're doing it wrong. Just do what works. It's right here above, incl. applicable links for further help. Why don't you spend a few minutes consciously going through that, instead of booking seemingly useless trainers? (We hear that all the time)


    Hi, I am Pradeep. My GSD is 8 months old. I find my dog intelligent than other GSDs i have seen. But he isn't a friendly dog other than our family. Hr barks and tends to bite every soul that visit us. I have heard GSD s are very friendly with kids, but Cesar runs towards kids to bite and you could feel the rage when he runs. Pls help.

    • supportive

      Pradeep, the RIGHT help is right here above. Read the first sentence, click the link, read again, and so on. Then apply what you've read here, and your dog will be friendly, with kids too.

      • mosquito-passing

        Mr pradeep its rather a common problem among GSD take some time to play with ur dog try to get a consolement with it have some training kit with u such that it doesnt bit the outsiders.... Hope u get this???


        Right Tim, I am often impressed how much patience you have, I to noticed that a lot are to lazy to read the the page they post their question - or to use the menu. So much quicker that way. But no, they are obsessed to spell out their question anyway. I would get really angry. Amazingly you rarely do.


    I have a Alaskan shepherd. Which I had found wondering the streets. Tried find his owners. Since that was a bust I decided to keep this wonderful dog. Now we think he's about 2 to 3 years old. He hasn't fully grown into his paws which are hide. He plays like a pup. He's been fixed. I would love to have more control of him. Since he's so big. He seems to know I'm in charge but he still tries to be dominate.


    my puppy is a GSD about a month old and likes to stuck herself in corners. she crys and trys to bites if she is picked up. i just got her yesterday and i would really appreciate some advice on how to bond and train her.


    We have a 3 yr old pure bread GSD, a 4 year old boxer/spaniel mix (rescue) and a Treeing walker coonhound (unknown age, rescue). Our GSD keeps lunging at/ barking at the other dogs if they approach the couch while my husband and I are on it, and she definitely barks/snarls at any other dog that looks at her while she is eating. When she lunges/barks at the other dogs, she stops just short of them, but never touches them, and they just ignore her. It is getting really old and frustrating to have this constantly going on in the house. Could you recommend or point me in the direction of how to train her to stop? When she is by herself with either my husband or myself this never happens and she obeys any command we give her...

  17. mosquito-passing

    I have a 8month old pup she does well with basic commands such as sit lay down etc however she jumps on ppl way too much and also has a problem with biting as she thinks she is playing I can't get her to stop biting she thinks she isn't doing anything wrong sometimes she bites too hard I'm worried she will hurt my son. Please help

  18. mosquito-passing

    how do I train my one month old gsd he is very smart but he sometimes become lazy nd what should I gave him as nutrition ....

  19. mosquito-passing

    my GSD will not stop barking and i am running out of patience, Tim is very obediant untill it comes to the noise: what do i do?


    sorry i forgot to add that i live in an apperment. the plus side is that i have a park a couple of houses down from me. is that still sutible for a GSD?

    • supportive

      Emma, an apartment can be adequate for "a small GSD cross" IF you commit to provide three hours of outdoor exercise each day?
      Also, you can indeed fully train a six year old dog, even if he "still needs to be taught basic training".
      "and if your dog is doing the wrong thing is it better to just ignore it?" - This depends on what behavior it is. Eg jumping up on you I would not ignore. Full details how to get the adult dog to behave well with you (and even without you, ie when you are away!) you find in House Training Dogs To Behave Well In A High Value Home.

      Taking on a six year old dog is certainly very wise: At that age they are much calmer than they are when the same dog was younger. Plus, if he has been in a shelter at that age, he knows how precious you are to him when you take him on (of course, subject to you treating the dog well).

      So, I would definitely support you in that decision.


    I have recently been to an adoption centre and have fallen madly in love with a German shepherd cross, he is quite small for his breed and he is already six year’s old. And still needs to be taught basic training.
    My question is: how do I teach an older dog better manner’s… and if your dog is doing the wrong thing is it better to just ignore it? Until it stops doing what it was doing? (like if it was jumping up on me should I ignore him?)

  22. mosquito-passing

    I just bought a German Sheapard. Still waiting to bring him home from his momma. What is the best way to potty train since I have heard not to yell or scold them. How do you go about doing it the right way without making him violent toward you or others.


    Hello, we just got a GSD puppy he is 14 weeks old, I am having a little trouble potty training, we let him out on the chain to go potty and all he does is jump up on the door to be let in, if we take him out on the leash all he does is sit by your feet. after about 2-5 min within being inside he ends up messing on the floor. And do they have a nervous tendencies? He walks around the house and wines, ( I think he has to go potty so I will let him outside but that's not the case with him) he constantly does this. I have a 3 year old and a 6 month old and he seems to be rather attached to both of them. Im just wondering if this is normal and what I should do about the potty training, my fiancé has different training ideas then I do and im not sure if that's maybe confusing him also?

    • supportive

      Yes Rickkie, likely it's confusing the poor pup. From what you write you need to do lots of things immediately. Indeed so much, that I better suggest you get the Puppy Development Guide - Puppy 101, and apply all of that by the end of this week.

      Also note that what you think "he seems to be rather attached to both of them" is normal puppy curiosity, but experience tells me that once your pup reaches ~5 months of age, you will suddenly think "he seems to be aggressive with them". Because it's a lack of socialization in your household, you need to implement systematic socialization right now, and INTENSE. Again see the Puppy 101, or for socialization alternatively Ian Dunbar's book After you get your puppy.


    I was thinking of adopting a 3 year old male german shepherd and the original owner said he is very set on showing he is the alpha male. I am worried about our three kids (7,5, and 2) and whether or not he will hurt them. I have read some of your showing the dog who is the alpha but I am worried about the time in between of us showing we are the alpha. Any advise on whether we should adopt a dog that is already 3?

    • supportive

      Christina, let me be frank: I would not adopt that dog. This is subject to the following considerations:

      - A dog owner that wants to give up his/her dog will position the dog in ..? The best light, yes!
      - Now if that very dog owner admits to you "he is very set on showing he is the alpha male", then that was the most diplomatic way to tell you "This dog is tough! I struggle myself! See if you can handle this dog"

      In other words, ask yourself (and ideally, the dog owner too!): WHY do you want to give up this dog?

      Now, regardless what the owner replies, (s)he said already a lot, maybe enough: "he is very set on showing he is the alpha male"!
      And you sound like you are a "normal" family - NOT a professional dog handler, right?
      Unless you have got the time (full-time!) to train the dog FROM THE FIRST DAY, and BEFORE your young(!) kids interact with the dog, you bear a RISK with a dog with such kind of background (as told by the owner)!

      In general, an older dog is actually SAFER for a family with small children (contrary to what most young families buy: a puppy!). HOWEVER: If the current (3-years-long!!!) owner was unable to become the dog's accepted Pack leader, then you need to ask yourself: "What makes me believe that I, and my husband, and my 7 year old, and my 5 year old, and my 2 year old will be able to become this dog's accepted Pack leader BEFORE sth can happen?"
      (yes, ALL family members MUST be established as ACCEPTED Pack leader, or you have a "ticking bomb" in your house)

      Sorry to be so direct.
      Will you let me know what you found out and how you decided?


    My Germain shepherd is not obedent but she is 10 weeks any idea of how to train her?


    Hi there! I have a 15 month old beautiful female named Heidi. We have had here since she was a pup, and unfortunately, failed to properly train her. She does not tear things up or use the bathroom in the house, but she does not obey very well. She jumps up on people any chance she gets, especially children-- just to lick them of course 🙂 With 5 kids in the house, we have been neglectful in teaching her basic commands. Is it too late for our Heidi dog to be properly trained and do the work that she desires to do?

    • supportive

      No Sarah, it's never too late (but obviously it gets more difficult when you start late).
      I'd start TODAY with what we teach here. Start with the Puppy Essentials in your case. Stick them on the fridge for all kids to observe, and then be consistent in applying them. wink


    I have an 11 week old german shepherd and I can already tell he is very smart. He sits, stays and shakes. 2 things he is having trouble with is biting and going to his crate. We've tried the basics to correct the biting and leading him to the crate but he is still struggling with both. Any suggestions?

  28. newbie

    Hi thank you for your work-I rescued a 1 yr old F gsd from a distant cousin who had to give her away. Successfully integrated with a 4pd 1yr old chihuahua (M) and 9 yr old beagle, the last couple weeks she has gotten aggressive and attacked the beagle for seemingly no reason with my husband (I am alpha)once outside then again inside after just having come in. She hurt the beagle and my husband as he had to get his hands in her mouth to save the beagle-she had to have surgery on her ear. We are hoping to have training soon, but any advice besides keeping them completely apart? Another cousin advised a soft muzzle, but that is a temp solution and I would prefer a permanent one. Thanks again!
    Perplexed in Pa Julie

    • supportive

      "successfully integrated" Julie?
      Okay. Well. There is little outside the (free) subscription we can do. Too busy.
      Had you subscribed you would have applied the GSD Training Essentials - as a minimum - and very likely that problem would never have occured! Sounds like a lot has gone wrong there. Also, your perception seems unjustified, sorry: Sounds like you are definitely not the alpha. There is no Pack leader for a dog unless you are the accepted Pack leader (see the Prime Secret about Dogs).

      I feel very sorry for the beagle, this should NEVER happen! It can have many reasons, or just one. One is unlikely here, but if so, it's probably that she still suffers traumatization from a prior experience/treatment. This should have been addressed immediately. Now, there is no quick fix, sorry. Separation is no solution. Fixing her aggression is the solution.


    My 3 year old male GSD within the last 1 or so wants to dart out the door and run away at every chance he gets! We do not have a fenced in yard as he was always fine before and never ran, he always was a very good listener and never wanted to leave us. We had considered breeding him so he hadn't gotten him neutered. Will neutering calm him down a bit? any suggesting on keeping him close?

    • supportive

      The sudden increase of enquiries on this public page strikes us with surprise. Can it be that another spammer is behind this?
      Let's find out: Kindly subscribe to get answers to your questions - like everyone else.


    Hi my boyfriend is really wanting to get a Germany Shepherd pup I already have a four months ago Jack Russell I'm not sure if it such a good idea. I am kinda worried that they won't get on.. A little advice would be a huge help


    I want to have a dog, Its been my dream since long, I m unmarried, but will be marrying soon, and later (as obvious), an infant or kids in my home.

    Labrador, Golden Retriever and German shepherd are my favorites.

    Want it to protect my family when I am not there.
    And it should not harm any family member even accidentally.

    I dont plan to keep him in a cage or chains,
    I am "not much social" and dont like a lot of visitors in my house.

    When should I adopt a dog, of what age, and which breed?

    • supportive

      Rohit, thanks for asking first! Being considerate as dog owner will be important.

      Here's my response:
      1) Whether any of the three could (accidentally or intentionally) harm a family member depends entirely on your training approach and on your family's behavior. If you get both right, it will never happen! All three breeds are very Pack-oriented and will love their Pack (unless of course not treated well, see above).

      The GSD is most Pack-oriented of these three breeds, because the German Shepherd is a herding dog (bred to look after the entire herd, here your family), while the Labrador (short for Labrador Retriever) and the Golden Retriever both are ... well, obviously Retrievers, bred to retrieve prey shot by their owner (a hunter/ranger).

      While most Retrievers these days are city dogs (not working dogs helping on a hunt), breed characteristics are not lost within a few hundred dog generations, this takes a few thousand generations. Note here that pet dogs really developed only since around the 1950s. Given say, an average one dog generation per year gives 60+ canine pet generations, that's not enough for breeders to change inherent breed characteristics.

      So, in short: The GSD still is a herding dog, and the Lab and Golden still are Retrievers. As a dog owner we can notice the consequential differences every day. Most but not all differences relate to the dog's behavior. So, while the GSD may not look as 'cuddly' as the Lab or Golden, the GSD in fact is more caring for its Pack than the other breeds.

      2) Your three favorites are a very good choice wink

      3) To protect your family, certainly the GSD is the best option (is more intimidating, and stronger).

      4) All three breeds (all dogs!) will NOT develop well if you:
      - keep them in an outdoor kennel
      - or they are chained
      - or they are left alone in the house all day while all family members are away
      - or they are not intensely socialized as a puppy!
      (Keep this list, it's crucial!)

      So if you "don't like visitors", don't get a dog(!), unless you will take your pup to say 200 places of friends, relatives, neighbors, colleagues, or strangers! But even then, a dog that doesn't learn to behave when a friendly visitor 'intrudes' his/her territory, will develop behavior problems. So, now you know what you're up to if you don't want to have visitors in your house. I am not criticising, I am only explaining the dog's view/behavior. Okay?
      (If you wonder "200 places??", well yes, get the Puppy Development Guide to understand)

      5) The right time for dog adoption is anytime when YOU are ready. See all above hints. So, this can be either before or after you marry and have kids. CRUCIAL will be that you establish ALL family members as the dog's Pack leader (how to do this is of course also explained in the Guide). If you don't, this may happen: "And it should not harm any family member even accidentally." !!

      6) Your final question, a dog of what age? Both pup and adult dog have advantages and disadvantages, and both cannot be avoided (search Google for this if you don't get the Guide). The point most dog owners do wrong is: They get a puppy for their small children ("let them have a cuddly playmate" etc). With small children, an adult dog is much safer (of course if trained well). But since you don't have children yet, you can get a puppy, (s)he will be adult long before the baby comes. wink

      Did I miss a point of yours?

      Edit: Oh, one more thing: If you really want to do the best for the dog (and for your family), then long before you get the dog, learn about having a dog. Our members often say they wished they had become a subscriber here a couple of years before they got their dog. Says everything, right? Exactly!


    I have a 8 month German Shepherd puppy. He is very hyper, which is expected since he is a puppy. He sits, stays, and knows how to walk on the leash a bit. But he has a jumping and barking problem. He jumps a lot, and he does it for no reason. We tell him to stop jumping and leave so he knows what he is doing is wrong but he still jumps. Where we live there are many other dogs but everyone seems to be scared of him. He barks a lot when he is in the backyeard but when we take him out to walks he is very calm. My neighbors look at him weird cause he is so good on the leash but they think he is aggressive. He likes to play harsh but he is just very playful. Any ideas?

    • supportive

      Loads. Have you studied our members' stuff? I'd start with the "essentials", then the Barking one, then the Jumping (which isn't as bad as you make it: He's a pup! Enjoy smile

  33. mosquito-passing

    Sasha is 8 months old. She doesn't mind riding in the vehicle. In fact, she seems to rather enjoy it. The problem is getting her in. I have to pick her up and put her on the seat. This isn't much of a problem, but i don't want this to add to her anxiety. Our other dogs just jump right in, so this situation has never happened before. Any suggestions would be greatly welcomed.

    • supportive

      Don't. Never (unless old).
      1) Any frailty? Are you sure?
      2) If no frailty, be more patient: Wait at least 10 or 20 min (yes!) - without looking, touching, speaking (I bet you don't at the moment, ha! wink
      Just open door, initial indication to hop in, if not, wait. And wait more.
      3) If still not, simulate you're driving off without her (use family member help). Again: without looking, touching, speaking (always).

      Why? Because, possible reasons: frailty, anxiety, or Pack leader demonstration (yes!). With the above, you find out which one. smile

  34. newbie

    Where could I go to learn how to train GSD to be service dogs and/or guard dogs. I am interested in becoming a professional trainer so want to attend a quality school.

    • supportive

      Where do you live? How far can you travel? How much can you spend?
      I doubt the APDT would be right for you, rather do what their members (dog trainers!) did themselves, just better: LEARN dog training through studying it yourself. THINK. APPLY. OBSERVE. RECONSIDER. APPLY. THINK. APPLY. OBS....

      Got it?

      Why? Cause if you merely follow what THEY do, you are merely copying what's done wrong, doh!

      (sorry if you don't like my answer, but you asked ME, right? wink

  35. newbie

    What do you mean our stop jumping advice? She is let out of the cage to run around. My boyfriend tells me that she will calm down with her getting older and just time in general. He hasn't gotten her fixed. He is afraid if the risks. Any advice about that?

    • supportive

      Of course we have as well, see the Spaying/Neutering Periodical.
      Really, there is no point in rehashing here in the comments section what is explained in depth in the Periodicals, articles, and books, is it?

      "She is let out of the cage to run around" - We are worlds apart, Elizabeth! I CANNOT start at point zero all over again for every new/old comment. We have Periodicals for everything.

  36. newbie

    My boyfriend has a german shepard that's almost a year old. Every time I visit and she is let out of her cage she jumps up on me. My boyfriend tells me that german Shepards are very difficult to train. I feel scared when ever I visit his house. Is there anything that I can do to feel safe again?

    • supportive

      Yes, get a new boyfriend who understands GSDs!
      German Shepherds are amongst the dogs EASIEST to train, tsss!
      Obviously your boyfriend isn't a member here. His fault.
      What you can/should do: Apply our Stop Jumping advice, of course!

      in a cage??? OMG! Poor dog.

  37. mosquito-passing

    my 11 month old puppy is one minded and only focus on her tennis ball, whenever we take it away to train her, she wont listen and only wants the ball, any help to break this addiciton to it

    • supportive

      Yes, first you need to become her accepted Pack leader - which clearly you are not right now. I suggest you apply both the Puppy and the Adult Dog Training Essentials Periodicals, as well as of course the Feeding Routine.

  38. mosquito-passing

    I have a 11mth. old german shepard puppy. She minds well on the leash. With the comands of Heel, Sit, Stay, Lie, Crawl and etc. However she is extremely aggressive towards to cats and dogs. We have two cats and did when we got her and have never had a dog who didn't like cats. However she was 6mths old when we got her. She was kept in a kennel with her dad and other puppy was the runt of the litter and had to fight for her food and etc. They didn't work with her at all. I am so frustrated with the issue of her aggressiveness I don't know what to do. Can you please help. I don't want to give up on her and have to sell her. She's a beautiful dog and has come so far in so many ways its the aggregation I'm afraid of. I hope you can help. Thank you, Darla Marlow

    • supportive

      Darla, pl apply the advice on introducing dog to resident cat and dog, Puppy Training Essentials, and the Desensitization. Is all in the Periodicals, and in my books. Repeating myself wouldn't improve a thing of what we have to offer.

1. To go live any bark must be relevant to this page idea
2. Be polite, discuss what you found, DON'T introduce yourself with what you want question
3. To fight SPAM anything with a link lands in SPAM. Also don't use: qf ??? \ * { } | [ ] because spammers do
"Published barks will be on-topic, helpful, and further the discussion" ok

 Say it


 Comments via our New Facebook Page Managed by Krystal! - Thank you xx


Jonathan: Thank you for your period advice. It is excellent! My GSD puppy is now 8 months and we read your advice regularly.

Dwayne: I love this site and the info you post onto it. Thanks again!!!!

Penny: Thanks for making your great articles available to all of us. it's nice to know that a recommended product is actually available in my country.

Stay with us and your dog will stay with you, both of you healthy and well-behaved.
If you are ever unhappy with anything we write, do or don't do, we want to be the first to know, thanks.

Disclaimer: Always apply your own common sense when you follow anyone's suggestions. As much as your dog is special (s)he may react different too. Note that when you click a link, for privacy reasons we will not share your browsing history, we do not use any tracking script and no Google Analytics. If you click through to a vendor and buy something, the vendor may share a commission with us or may not, only Amazon links always will.

© MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG - All content is protected. You must not copy or spin or otherwise change our content to republish it in your name, another one's name or without a name. If you wish to make use of our Intellectual Property Rights contact MYGERMANSHEPHERD.ORG. Thank you.

There's nothing quite like a healthy and well-behaved dog who freely guards every corner of your home, who brings you peace, who brings you joy
Welcome to The Cynology Hub MyGermanShepherd.Org Saves Health, Cost, Lives!
Devoted to serving all well-meaning dog owners, fosterers, and trainers
We help YOU that YOUR DOG does not end up in a(nother) shelter - Nor at a costly incompetent vet
228 database queries, 1.88 seconds, 25MB